Different genres demand different feels. Here's what works for rock, jazz, metal, and acoustic.
Versatility is key. Medium-thickness picks (0.88mm-1.0mm) handle both power chords and lead lines. A medium Delrin-style pick is a common workhorse—durable, grippy, and balanced. For blues bends and vibrato, a slightly thicker pick gives more control without sacrificing dynamics.
Precision above all. Thick picks (1.14mm+) with sharp tips cut through high-gain with clarity. Jazz III and Flow shapes dominate—small bodies force a tight grip close to the string. Stiff materials like Ultem/PEI and firm Nylon keep attack consistent at speed.
Articulation and warmth. Jazz III-style shapes are popular because the small, pointed shape allows precise comping and single-note runs. Thick Nylon or Ultem/PEI can deliver a round, clear attack. Many jazz players experiment with extra-thick picks (2mm+) for maximum control.
Flex and forgiveness. Thin to medium picks (0.5mm-0.88mm) strum chords without overwhelming the acoustic's natural resonance. The flex softens attack and adds a "sweep" to strummed patterns. For fingerstyle-hybrid, try a medium pick with a rounded tip.
Genre isn't destiny—plenty of jazz players use thicker Delrin-style picks, and metal guitarists have strummed acoustic with thin Nylon. But certain pick characteristics align naturally with certain styles.
Rock and blues live in the middle. You need a pick that can handle both rhythm and lead without switching. A medium thickness around 0.88mm to 1.0mm is a popular default because it’s stiff enough for clear single notes but flexible enough for dynamic strumming. Matte finishes help with sweaty hands under stage lights.
Metal and shred prioritize speed and precision. Thick, small picks (Jazz III, Flow) minimize the distance between your fingers and the string. This tightens your attack and reduces the "slop" that can creep in at high tempos. Stiff materials like Ultem/PEI help keep every note defined, even through heavy distortion.
Jazz values warmth and control. The Jazz III shape gives you pinpoint accuracy for chord voicings and bebop lines. Thicker gauges (1.38mm+) let you "dig in" without the pick flexing away. Some jazz players go even thicker—2mm or 3mm—for an almost pick-less feel with maximum control.
Acoustic and folk reward dynamics. Thin picks flex on contact, which softens the initial attack and lets the guitar's body resonate. This is ideal for strumming—you get a full, even chord sound without harsh transients. For acoustic lead work, step up to a medium pick for more articulation.
Use these as starting points, then experiment. Your technique, your guitar, and your ears will guide you to the right pick.
Take our 2-minute quiz and get personalized recommendations based on your playing style.
Most metal guitarists prefer thick picks (1.14mm+) with pointed tips like Jazz III or Flow shapes. The stiffness provides precise attack needed for fast alternate picking and palm-muted riffs. Ultem/PEI materials are popular for their clarity through high gain.
Thin to medium picks (0.5-0.88mm) work best for acoustic strumming. The flex softens the attack and lets chords ring naturally without harsh transients. Many acoustic players prefer Nylon or thin Delrin picks.
Many jazz guitarists prefer Jazz III style picks for their small, precise shape that allows clean chord voicings and bebop lines. Thick gauges (1.38mm+) are common for control. However, jazz is diverse—some players use standard picks or even their fingers.